A CFO’s Guide to Evaluating IT Investments with Confidence
Evaluating information technology can be one of the most difficult responsibilities in the CFO’s role. With an ever-growing list of IT requests—ranging from essential upgrades to innovative new tools—it’s not always clear which investments will lead to real business value and which are shiny distractions.
The technical complexity of many proposed IT solutions can make it difficult for non-technical leaders to gauge the potential ROI. At the same time, CFOs can’t afford to overlook technologies that might deliver a competitive edge—or worse, enable competitors to leap ahead.
This CFO’s guide to evaluating IT will help you navigate the gray areas, reduce risk, and make better-informed technology decisions.
Why Evaluating IT Is So Challenging for CFOs
Many CFOs are rightfully cautious about approving IT investments. You may have had previous experiences where major investments failed to deliver on their promises, costing time, money, and internal trust.
But playing it too safe has its risks. Delaying or rejecting key IT initiatives could hinder growth or allow competitors to capitalize on technology you didn’t adopt soon enough.
To strike the right balance, CFOs need better communication, a structured decision-making process, and a strategic lens for viewing technology investments.
Communication Is the Starting Point
One of the biggest challenges in evaluating IT is the communication gap between finance and technology teams.
Apples and Oranges
The CIO and IT staff are often focused on what technology can enable—new capabilities, improved performance, or competitive differentiation. On the other hand, finance teams are focused on cost control, ROI, and risk. These priorities don’t always align easily, and the language used by each group can feel like a different dialect.
Unhealthy Misalignment
In dysfunctional organizations, this divide gets worse. IT teams may push for technologies that don’t align with business needs, while finance teams might delay essential investments due to a lack of clarity or confidence in the proposed benefits. Both extremes are dangerous.
Find Common Ground Between Finance and IT
To bridge the gap, CFOs and CIOs need to speak a shared language: business impact. Every technology proposal should answer these questions:
-
What company-wide goals does this investment support?
-
Are there more cost-effective alternatives that still achieve those goals?
-
What metrics will we gain or improve with this technology?
-
Can we track progress and measure ROI throughout implementation?
-
If it doesn’t work, is there an exit plan?
These questions reframe the conversation around what matters most—business success, rather than individual department needs.
Establish a Clear Approval Structure
Conflicts over IT spending often arise in organizations lacking a well-defined approval process. Ask yourself:
-
Do you approve of every IT spend? If not, who does?
-
What thresholds trigger the need for CFO-level approval—budget size, contracts, operational impact?
-
Is there a process in place for appealing a denied request?
A clear, documented structure ensures accountability and helps avoid confusion or conflict. In larger organizations, it may not be feasible for the CFO to approve every IT project, but clarity on roles and thresholds is essential.
Visualize Your IT Strengths and Vulnerabilities
When evaluating IT priorities, it’s helpful to visualize the current state of your technology landscape:
-
What systems are performing well?
-
Where are your vulnerabilities—outdated software, underperforming infrastructure, unsupported tools?
-
What functions does the business need but can’t currently support?
-
Are there IT solutions available to address those gaps?
Mapping out strengths and weaknesses allows for strategic prioritization, helping you invest in areas that will have the greatest impact.
Final Thoughts: A Smarter Approach to IT Evaluation
Evaluating IT doesn’t have to be a guessing game. By improving communication, defining your decision-making process, and grounding every conversation in business goals, you can avoid missteps and build a future-ready IT strategy.
When CFOs and CIOs align, the organization wins.
Looking for strategic IT guidance that speaks your language?
Contact us today to start a conversation about aligning your technology investments with business success.
📞 Call us at (248) 349-6115
